Chuyển đến nội dung chính

The George Floyd verdict would not have happened

 The George Floyd verdict would not have happened 

The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends towards justice.” President Obama was fond of the saying and used it often – but it could do with a second part. The arc of the moral universe does not bend on its own. It is bent in the right direction by protesters, campaigners and dissenters. It was their hands that forced it towards justice last week, when the former police officer Derek Chauvin was found guilty of the second-degree murder of George Floyd. We cannot celebrate and take comfort in the verdict that was meted out without acknowledging the action outside the courtroom that secured it.


But this is what some will do: claim the verdict to be a great victory, after denigrating the means by which it was achieved. The protests in the wake of Floyd’s murder have been called the largest in US and global history. They reached more than 50 countries. In the US, tens of millions of dollars were raised and invested in grassroots communities and advocacy in a diffuse, decentralised network that lobbied politicians and pushed through voter registration. It all made a deep impression on the public consciousness. Chauvin quite simply would not have been brought to trial on these charges, let alone been convicted, were it not for these tireless efforts.

Some of those politicians are now shimmying to catch a bit of Floyd’s halo. The New York mayor, Bill de Blasio, said that “justice was served” after “the reality of racism in this nation finally hit a boiling point”. But he defended police driving into protesters who had reached that boiling point, saying that it was “inappropriate for protesters to surround a police vehicle and threaten police officers”. In the UK, Boris Johnson “welcomed” the verdict, after spending last summer urging people not to support Black Lives Matter demonstrations, which he decided were “in all probability going to end in violence”. Sajid Javid, the former home secretary, tweeted, “Justice. Black lives matter”, seemingly forgetting that last year he said the organisation was “not a force for good” and demanded protesters “show some goddamn respect”.

But this is how progress is won: by not showing goddamn respect. It isn’t handed over by the benign powers that govern us, but wrested from their hands through protest, riots and civil disobedience. Chauvin’s conviction was not the only legal consequence of last year’s mobilisations. From forcing Emmanuel Macron to put reform of the French police on the table to catalysing change in newsrooms in the US, the consequences were manifold. This type of dissent is responsible for many of the rights we all enjoy today, from universal suffrage in the UK to civil rights for black people in the US.


But there is a broader reason why the protests were being written out of history the moment they began to have an impact. As such movements gain momentum, their reach becomes impossible to contain. The charge that Black Lives Matter is a radical movement is correct. For it to achieve its goals, for racial equity to be achieved, a wholesale rethinking of power relations – between boss and employee, border guard and migrant, ruler and ruled – must take place. A grand redistribution of wealth is essential. A fallen statue is not about a mindless moment of anger, it is a demand to fundamentally and honestly rethink a particular country’s history and sense of self.

The uncomfortable truth is that change comes about in ways that are disruptive and, yes, occasionally unsavoury. Those events are then sanitised and their significance minimised, so we can maintain a naive trust in the arc of history and those who govern us. Every legal system is as flawed and institutionally skewed as the country in which it exists. In the UK and the US, it has inbuilt biases in favour of the police and those who can afford the best legal representation. Those who cannot afford it, from marginalised communities, are subject to criminalisation, becoming forever felons in the eyes of the state.

But the justice system is also sensitive to public opinion and the political environment, and its outcomes are often an interplay between external pressures and internal deficiencies. Accountability for George Floyd’s death may have been delivered in a courtroom, but it began in the streets.

Nhận xét

Bài đăng phổ biến từ blog này

Fast And Furious 9 It's A Series Of Tubes!

 If a UDP port scan reveals a vulnerability that allows you a root shell, the firewall is not "pretty good" as they state in the first part though. wouldn't a quantum-temporal mainframe just be how time flows within sub-molecular systems? ie exactly the same as how time flows normally? I see what you mean, but even with that addition, it definitely still needs some rephrasing to make sense...and even more rephrasing for it to be something a security expert would actually say. I’m afrad to ask, but isn’t this fairly accurate? Especially for this franchise! They’re basically stating someone blocked all tcp but left an exposed UDP root shell running somewhere on an important… nevermind, got it. Yeah but having root access just sitting there for the taking on an open port isn't "pretty good" or "perfect." Fast and Furious 9 All Casts Signature for Fan T-Shirt Now, if an open port allowed the attacker to talk to a running process with some shitty restri

Nick Castellanos deal on Major League Baseball

Nothing, really. It's a fair contract for a free agent with his skillset, and he's going to be playing in a home ballpark that will play well to his skills. Castellanos is a good hitter, but not a great one, and his only distinctive skill is power. But the Cincinnati ballpark favors a power hitter, and Castellanos is likely to increase his home run output playing there. The Reds realized this, and since they could sign him without upsetting their salary structure, they did so. They're trying to contend now and he should help. The only one that I think it’s not realistic for someone to break is the 511 career pitching wins amassed by Cy Young. No one else, even in Young’s own time, ever had more than 417 (Walter Johnson), and the most by a modern-era pitcher is the 355 of Greg Maddux. Nick Castellanos On Purpose T-Shirt Young pitched in a very different era, where pitchers didn’t go all-out on every pitch, and by all accounts he was a freak of nature anyway—a guy who was abl

Tebow to a one-year deal to play

 Tim Tebow is coming back to the NFL. After a six-year hiatus, the Jaguars plan to sign the former NFL quarterback to a one-year deal, CBS Sports' Jonathan Jones confirmed. As previously reported, Tebow will play tight end for the Jaguars.  Tim Tebow Hes A Winner , 33, recently worked out for the Jaguars and head coach Urban Meyer, who coached Tebow during his record-setting run at the University of Florida. A former Heisman Trophy winner, Tebow went 9-7 as the Broncos' starting quarterback before spending one season with the New York Jets. He then had two uneventful stops with the Jets and Patriots before spending nearly five years in the Mets' minor league system.  Along with playing tight end, Tebow may be asked to serve as a mentor for quarterback Trevor Lawrence, the No. 1 overall pick in the draft. Like Tebow, Lawrence led his collegiate team to a national championship before becoming a first-round pick.  The most important thing for Trevor is to learn the offense, it